Is the current rite of episcopal ordination invalid?
The short answer
No. A sacrament requires proper matter and form. Jesus did not mandate a particular formula for consecrating bishops, so the Church has authority over it; when she authorizes a formula, we can be certain it is effective.
Matter and form
For any sacrament to be valid, the proper matter and form must be observed.
The Church's authority
Jesus did not prescribe a specific formula for consecrating bishops, so the Church has authority to determine it. When she officially authorizes a formula, we can be certain of its efficacy.
The objection
Those who insist other particular words are absolutely necessary apparently do not understand the authority Jesus gave the apostles.
Continue exploring
- A woman was "ordained" a bishop and then ordained others. Is this valid?Q&A
- Can I be ordained online to officiate a wedding?Q&A
- Can deacons give blessings?Q&A
- Deacons can't celebrate Mass, so why can't women be ordained deacons?Q&A
- Given the priest shortage, why does the Latin Church force its priests to be celibate?Q&A
- What are the seven sacraments?Q&A