Shouldn't everyone take the same postures at Mass as a sign of unity?
The short answer
Yes, a common posture is a sign of unity — and the correct posture during the consecration is kneeling. The General Instruction says the faithful kneel from after the Sanctus until after the Amen of the Eucharistic Prayer, unless prevented.
A sign of unity
A common posture expresses and fosters the unity and spiritual attitude of those gathered (GIRM 42).
Kneeling is correct
The faithful should kneel from after the Sanctus until after the Amen of the Eucharistic Prayer, unless prevented by health, lack of space, large crowds or another good reason (GIRM 43). So those kneeling during the consecration are keeping the correct posture.
Reverence at Communion
Separately, out of reverence, communicants bow their heads before receiving (GIRM 160).
Continue exploring
- Should we kneel at Mass?Q&A
- Can a lay pastoral coordinator give a homily?Q&A
- Can non-Catholics participate in the gestures at Mass?Q&A
- Did the Church change the Mass to make it more acceptable to Protestants?Q&A
- Doesn't the new Mass reject Pius V's mandate in Quo Primum?Q&A
- I don't like the Novus Ordo and can't get to the old Mass every week. Is it a sin not to go?Q&A