Aren't pro-life Catholics who support a war being hypocritical?
The short answer
No. War can sometimes be morally justified, so Catholics may disagree about whether a particular war is just. Abortion, euthanasia, embryonic stem-cell research and human cloning can never be justified, because they always involve the illegitimate killing of innocent human beings.
War can be justified
Because there are cases in which war is morally justifiable, Catholics are free to disagree about whether a given war meets that standard.
Some acts never can be
Abortion, euthanasia, embryonic stem-cell research and human cloning are never justifiable, since each involves the illegitimate killing of innocent human beings. No Catholic may ever support them.
No contradiction
A pro-life Catholic who rightly rejects the killing of the innocent can, without inconsistency, judge a particular war to be justified according to the Church's just war doctrine.
Continue exploring
- Can a Catholic believe the U.S. was justified in dropping atomic bombs on Japan?Q&A
- Is there an actual quote from John Paul II saying life begins at conception?Q&A
- What does the Catholic Church teach about abortion?Q&A
- What does the Church teach about euthanasia and assisted suicide?Q&A
- Can homologous artificial insemination be permitted as a treatment for male infertility?Q&A
- Does the Church teach it is better to die than to be raped?Q&A