Catholic.id

Salvation & Last ThingsDeep dive

Is the Catholic Church Arminian rather than Calvinist?

Salvation & Last Things

The short answer

Neither label fits: the Church came before Arminianism and isn't a product of it. Better to say Calvinism and Arminianism each agree with Catholicism on some points and differ on others.

The Church came first

The Catholic Church cannot be called Arminian; it predates Arminianism and is not a product of it.

Calvinism

John Calvin's system, remembered as TULIP: total depravity, unconditional election, limited atonement, irresistible grace, perseverance of the saints.

Arminianism

Named for Jacobus Arminius, summarized in the five articles of the Remonstrants: apart from grace man can do nothing truly good, conditional election, unlimited atonement, resistible grace, and the possibility of apostasy.

Agreement and disagreement

Catholic theologians from Aquinas to Bellarmine have taught unconditional election, as Calvinists do; but the Church does not teach that all believers are predestined to persevere. With Arminians, the Church teaches universal redemption; but she allows for the possibility of unconditional election.