How can the Church of St. Pius X be compared with that of John Paul II?
The short answer
Without specific charges, they can't really be compared. Both popes were innovators — Pius X shocked many by admitting children of seven to Communion and urging frequent Communion. The Church's practice and understanding develop, as a man grows from childhood while staying the same person; both can be holy popes.
Specific charges needed
Without specific issues to examine, the pontificates of Pius X (1903–1914) and John Paul II (1978–2005) can't be compared.
Both innovators
Pius X opened Communion to children as young as seven and urged frequent, even daily, Communion — innovations that shocked many in his day.
Growth, same substance
The Church's pastoral practice, liturgical discipline and even understanding of doctrine develop over time. As a man looks different from the child he was but is the same person, the Church may look different yet remain substantially the same. Both can be holy popes devoted to the Church.
A suggestion
Study more closely the specific issues that trouble you; there may be a misunderstanding or a gap in knowledge of what the faith allows.
Continue exploring
- Did Fulton Sheen support Vatican II?Q&A
- Did Pope Leo X say "It has served us well, this myth of Christ"?Q&A
- Did the Church change its doctrine during the Counter-Reformation?Q&A
- Does a photo of a papal representative at a pagan shrine mean the Church accepts pagan religions?Q&A
- Newman said "to be deep in history is to cease to be Protestant." Why don't more Protestant historians become Catholic?Q&A
- Should John Paul II have retired because of his infirmity?Q&A